EXR issues - Color background changes + jagged edges

Started by PeterSwift, May 01, 2018, 12:51:51 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

PeterSwift

If I have a solid colored background background with a specific RGB and render that out with EXR. The color becomes slighty brighter. Is this a bug. Limitations of the file format or what? :) Does not happen with PNG for example.
I also found another bug or probably a limitation of EXR. IF you use transparancy. It will get very jagged edges. impossible to change background color in post for example. But if I use transparent PNG, it is really smooth edges.
This should be written in a info square, when you select format. So people learn/know of these limitations :)

DriesV

I can't reproduce the jagginess with transparency.
Can you show an example?

Dries

PeterSwift

Quote from: DriesV on May 01, 2018, 11:58:05 AM
I can't reproduce the jagginess with transparency.
Can you show an example?

Dries


For sure, no problem.
In premiere it looks like this.  With EXR, vs PNG. just as a quick comparison.

Just ontop of a colored background.


DriesV

Can you share the original files? EXR and PNG renderings and Premiere project.

Dries

PeterSwift

Quote from: DriesV on May 02, 2018, 01:34:09 AM
Can you share the original files? EXR and PNG renderings and Premiere project.

Dries

Afraid not. But I will look into doing some testing with something I can share. Ill come back to you about that.